The day after the presidential election of 1912, 13-year-old Medora Espy wrote
to her mother:
Isn’t it awful that the Democrats have won all over the U.S.? Wilson president,
Lister governor and 294 Democrats in Congress, 125 Republicans and 16
Progressives. I have been wearing a Bull Moose pin but since the election my pin
is put safely away where I shall keep it and show my grandchildren the badge the
progressives wore the first year of the Progressive Party...
I am anxious to know the County returns.
What is good for Hay Fever? Ans. Listerine. [Medora’s joke refers to the
newly elected Governor of Washington, Ernest Lister (D. 1913-1919), and his
defeated opponent, Governor Marion E. Hay (R. 1909-1913)].
Medora’s interest in and concern over the election results might seem unusual
given the time period, her gender, and her age. However, she was not a "usual"
girl, nor was she from a"usual" family.
Medora Espy was the eldest of Helen Richardson and state senator Harry Albert
Espy’s seven children. In November 1912 she was a freshman at Olympia High
School, staying at the home of"Mrs. Eadie" at 15th and Adams Streets in the
state capital. The boarding arrangement was temporary while Medora awaited the
arrival of the rest of her family, at which time they would all take up residence
in a rental house. The move would be in time for the beginning of the 13th
session of the Washington State Legislature, during which Papa was serving the
last year of his term (1911-1913) as senator from the 19th District representing
Pacific and Wahkiakum Counties.
Home for Medora and her family was the tiny, tumbledown village of Oysterville
in the southwestern corner of the state. Once a pioneer boomtown and Pacific
County seat, Oysterville was now an all-but-forgotten backwater where the 50 or
60 residents managed to fish or farm or otherwise eke out a subsistence living.
Oysterville was where Robert Hamilton Espy, co-founder of the town and Medora’s
venerated grandfather, still lived with his third wife, "Aunt Kate," and where
Papa operated his dairy farm. It was where Mama managed the household full of
Medora’s younger siblings, yet still found time to write to her eldest daughteralmost daily. And, it had been in Oysterville during the past summer that Medora,
along with nearly everyone in town, eagerly awaited the latest word from Papa
during the six long weeks that he was gone from home. That was when Papa was a
delegate to the 1912 Republican National Convention.
To be accurate, Papa was an alternate delegate. Even so, his role during the
state caucuses proved an important one, and during the five days of the
convention in Chicago, June 8-22, he participated as fully as opportunities
presented themselves. The experience was certainly the highlight of his short
political career, and his children long spoke of the time that Papa was a
delegate. Even I, a grandchild born during his dotage, heard him speak of that
unforgettable trip.
The letters Papa wrote home during that long-ago summer reveal that the family
stories originating from"when Papa was a delegate" referred to far more than his
duties at the convention. The trip itself was the experience of a lifetime for
Papa, then a 36-year-old dairyman from the Far West. And now, nearly 100 yearslater, the letters reveal much about Papa-the-husband-and-father, Harry-the-
dairyman, and Senator Espy-the-politician.
Papa left Oysterville on Monday, June 10, no doubt riding his horse Nick the four
miles south to Nahcotta. There, as was his custom, he removed Nick’s bridle, tied
it to the saddle, and gave Nick a slap, sending him homeward. Papa then caught
the little steamer Reliable (or perhaps her sister ship, the
Shamrock), and crossed the bay to the "new" county seat of South Bend1
where the following morning he would catch the train for Centralia and points
north and east.
Papa’s first message home was written that night from Cassels’ Hotel in South
Bend. On the back of an International Bank deposit slip he gave Mama detailed
instructions on how to fill out such slips should the need arise. He continued
to write daily, directing Mama with regard to business matters, expressing
concern about the dairy farm, and providing specific directions for her to give
the hired men regarding care of the livestock, mending fences, and the planting
and harvesting of crops. But gradually, as the miles clicked by, his thoughts
turned toward the work that lay ahead in Chicago. [NOTE: Only excerpted portions
of Papa’s 1912 correspondence are included here. The letters, along with Mama’s
responses, are part of the Espy archives housed at the Washington State History
Research Center.]
Seattle, 8 a.m. [Thursday]
June 13, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Am just settled on Northern Pacific Atlantic Express Train #4 leaving Seattle at
8:45 a.m. and to reach Chicago at noon Sunday.
Come back by Denver, Salt Lake, Huntington & Portland. Round trip $72.50. Could
have returned via Los Angeles for 75.00 and came near doing it but feared I might
not have time as it would take 2 days longer...
Harry
[Saturday]
June 15, 1912
My Dearest Helen,
Wish you would get from Aunt Kate the names and addresses of our various
relatives in Ohio and Pennsylvania and send them to me.
Looking at the map, the distance seems so short compared with the distance I have
come, I am nearly persuaded to go see them-particularly if our Roosevelt
delegation fails to be seated-as seems not unlikely. Today’s paper says they have
thrown out Texas which was on a par with Wash. And I presume we will get the ax
also.
Another thing for you to do. I meant to have brought that book relating to the
claims of the Chinook Indians [see sidebar, "Still Pending," below] against the
Gov’t but failed to do so. It is a black book about like "Ryans Manual of the
Legislatur...," and is in my desk some where near the top. I think it is in tha
middle partition between the pigeon-holes with the company check book and Minute
Book. Be sure not to spill anything out of either of those, but if you can, would
like you to find that book & see the number of the "Senate bill" it refers to
near the start (5 thousand and something, I think) & inform me by first letter.
If I go to Washington, will try to get the matter pushed through...
Give love to all. Address mail to LaSalle hotel, though later may have you
change. Notice our people are at "Congress" hotel.
Lovingly, Harry
Congress Hotel and Annex, Chicago
[Sunday,] June 16, 1912
Dearest Helen,
I am in the big town, writing this on the arm of a chair in this hotel
lobby
The noise is deafening-arguments and counter arguments-but no one appears to be
getting anywhere.
I expect you may see in tomorrow’s (Monday’s) paper a statement of our delegation
anent [concerning] the unseating thereof by the nat’l committee.
The idea & rough draft were by Poindexter.2 A Committee of 3 was appointed to
make it-on which I was not-but the final refinement & force, such as it may have,
is in great part due to yours truly. I did the most of the cutting out-strange
part for me to take, to cut out-but I did. You may think it might have been cut
more-but had difficulty in getting that much. We merely meant to get a statement
which would appeal to the delegates who are on the fence as to whether they will
stand for the "rawness" of the Taft people on the Nat’l Committee
I arrived about 2 o’clock p.m. & spent the most of the afternoon finding a room-
then in locating our people.
Then it was a matter of conference & reconference of our delegates. Then a
conference of all the Roosevelt delegates-assignment of work to win over the
necessary doubtful delegates bound to Taft but by ties that may be broken.
I have room 767 Palmer House-a top room in what was ten y’rs ago the house of the
town but now 2nd or 3rd rate. $3.00 per day for room which is in itself O.K. but
on floor I think ordinarily used by hotel help. Rates here are $13.00 per-
cheapest. LaSalle about $5.00 cheapest. Four men are there in 2 small joining
rooms at $14.00. That is headquarters of Washington Roosevelt delegation. Was
disappointed in not finding any mail from you but trust all is O.K.
If you want me suddenly for anything wire c/o "Washington Roosevelt Delegation,
LaSalle Hotel." You may also continue to write me there, tho I am staying at the
Palmer House
Have just run across Lorenzo Dow of Tacoma whom you probably remember as a
member of the lower house last year at Olympia, and he is going to stay with me
tonight. He has room out in suburbs some where with friends of his friends in
Tacoma & does not want to run in on them at this time of night
I believe I will go [to Pennsylvania] to see Chas. Oliver & such other relatives
as I find handy there. It only costs about $6.00...and so long as I am so near
think I should take it in
Will also probably go to Washington D.C., if my money holds out & try to get that
Chinook Indian matter moving, if possible. If I can get that thru it will mean a
great deal to our people there...[W]ill close with a hug and armful of kisses for
yourself & the babies. Wish you would suggest what trinket I should bring to
each.
Lovingly, Harry
Congress Hotel and Annex, Chicago
[Monday,] June 17, 1912
Dearest Helen,
This has been a busy day with very little accomplished. Stood opposite to
Roosevelt for half an hour as crowd was filing thru shaking hands and had good
opportunity to observe him-which I did to the limit. Certainly very energetic and
later made a wonderful speech in Auditorium to big crowd.
It looks doubtful if I will get much out of this trip as the man for whom I am
alternate is not only present, but very active.
Went thru Marshall Field’s big store during the afternoon-the biggest in the
world. That is all the sight-seeing I have done so far....
Think you and Aunt Kate are wrong about my traveling with the rest of the crowd.
I sure would like to have done so but they are spenders and I would have to keep
up my end, or else be worse off than not to be with them. I see enuf of them here
to spend more than I can afford and at the same time must seem tight to them. I
sneak around and eat a sandwich instead of going with the rest to dinner because
the latter means a couple dollars-although they decided before I came that each
man should stand his own dinner but you can’t order much different from the rest
and must stand some things for all once in a while when the rest are doing right
along.
So much for doldrums. Am having a fine experience in spite of lack of money.
There is great excitement and strong tension here tonight, getting ready for the
big time tomorrow. It is the most momentous incident or convention for the Rep.
Party in 20 years, and will probably be the last great onas in all probabiliyt it will be settled by district primaries hereafter....3
Lovingly, Harry
National Roosevelt Committee, Chicago
[Tuesday,] June 18, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Have had a very exciting day & took all thereof to effect the temporary
organization, which was finally controlled by the Taft forces by the use of
illegal votes from Washington, Texas, California, Arizona, Alabama & some others.
Also, some delegates from Oregon, Maryland & other states honestly elected but
instructed for Roosevelt voted with the Taft people on organization. Just the
same as in our County & State Conventions.
We (Roosevelt men) have caucused & recaucused & word is now given out that we are
going to have Roosevelt any way, & that tomorrow will decide it. There are many,
however, who prophesy that there will be a deadlock and that we will be tied up
here for two weeks. If so they will certainly have to give us cheaper rooms. I,
for one, can not stand $3.00 per day for long. In fact, I am going to make a
strong try tomorrow to do better.
Was very glad this evening to get your letter of the 14th-the second so far since
my arrial... Was very glad to know that Joe had the wind mill to working. Hope
it continues O.Ktell him to put new brake wire on it, and to shut it off
whenever not necessary torun-so not to wear the pump (nor mill either) any morethan necessary. Hope he is getting in the oats O.K. & don’t let him forget to
have the thickest part of those ferns on the oats he just harrowed-mowed, if
possible. Have them cut high so not to injure the oats under them & the will de....
Lovingly, Harry
Palmer House, Chicago
[Wednesday,] June 19, 1912
Dearest Helen,
There is no news again today.
There has been much of interest in connection with the convention, but you will
get it in much better form & greater detail in the paper than I could attempt to
write.
Our people lost the fight again today & it is probable there will be two
Republican parties tomorrow. Some were anxious to withdraw today but my
contention has been to carry the question to the highest tribunal they offer
before withdrawing. That means that we will have a majority & minority report of
the credentials committee & if the majority report is sustained & the members who
are challenged as to their seat, are allowed to vote on their own cases, the
Roosevelt forces will probably hold a convention oftheir own....
Lovingly, Harry
Palmer House, Chicago
[Friday,] June 21, 1912
Dearest Helen,
It is nearly morning so presume I should call it the 21st.
Another day has gone & we are still dead locked. That is the Taft people have a
majority of the delegates on the organization but are not sure of enough to
nominate, so are marking time & trying to wear the Roosevelt forces out.
We have not been seated but the Taft people are said to have offered to seat us &
California if we would then agree to abide by the decision of the majority. Our
people, however, have refused to be bound by the votes of any stolen delegates,
even if ours areseated....
Late so will close.
Lovingly, Harry
Windsor-Clifton Hotel, Chicago
[Saturday,] June 22, 1912
Dearest Helen,
The convention is over-or maybe I should say conventions are over-and both Taft &
Roosevelt are nominated. I had a hand in the latter but none in the former. Have
moved from the Palmer to this hotel where I get a room for half the price... Took
ride in auto with four others of our men today, my first dissipation. Went thru
Lincoln Park & beyond. Wish I could see the wheat-pit & stock yards before I
leave, but fear I will not..
Had two conventions-Taft & Roosevelt-today so am tired & will draw to close. Hope
babes are much better now. With much love to them & yourself, I am,
Lovingly, Harry
Papa wrote the next several letters while visiting "the relatives" in Newcastle,
Portersville, and Youngstown, Pennsylvania. These were his Espy cousins, several
of whom he had not met previously-the children and grandchildren of his father’s
sister and brother. Of the countryside he commented: "A very beautiful country, I
think. Very hilly, but all farmed. If it just had the old bay somewhere near, I
would like it fine." Then it was back to business as he headed for Washington,
D.C., to meet with legislators regarding the concerns of his Chinook Indian
constituency at home.
Washington, D.C.
Saturday, June 29, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Another very busy day.
Been working on Indian claims...then had dinner with Poindexters & remained with
them till 10 P.M.-then walked with him & Johnson of Seattle of Roosevelt
delegation to points of interest till about 1 a.m. June 30. Then have been
looking up schedules to get to Atlantic City tomorrow until now is 2:00 a.m. and
I must get train at 9:10 so should get to bed.
Saw library, capitol, Gen. Land Office & Senate & House Office buildings inside,
rest outside. Then did work on Indian claims. Am hungry for you. No word since
left Chicago.
Lovingly, Harry
Hotel Astor, Times Square, New York
[Monday,] July 1, 1912
Dearest Helen,
I left Washington at 9:10 yesterday A.M...went to Atlantic City, arriving at 3:00
P.M. Was considerably disappointed there in smallness of the crowds-though there
were some more than in Oysterville-but have now been and feel that it is
worthwhile as I can talk with intelligence when, as is always the case, the
person I am telling about the glories of our beach wishes me to compare it to
Atlantic City...
Of course...even with all day tomorrow can only touch a few of the many things
one should see after coming this far, but I am really getting ashamed of myself
staying so long, with you there home alone with all the irksome things you have
to contend wit...I still hope this trip will be the means of making future trips
for us both possible.
Lovingly, Harry
National Hotel, Washington D.C.
[Thursday,] July 4, 1912
Dearest Helen,
It is still the "glorious fourth" tho it will not be for long. It is quite warm
yet at 11:30 but has not been so hot as was yesterday. Came down from New York in
a sweltering heat yesterday and our train (not me) missed connections at
Philadelphia making me arrive here (at Depot) 10 p.m. Then went to capitol
inquiring for Warburton4 & Poindexter, especially former as was told the House
was in session but found it was no....
After a long time located him and got back to hotel nearly one a.m. Had expected
mail from you but finding none decided to wire you....
Got up to keep 9:30 appointment with Warburton which did without breakfast only
to wait for him to about 11:00 (tho he had told me he might be late-but want you
to know that I was not the late one), then went over and found Poindexter and was
prevailed upon to go with him to lunch at 2 p.m. when needless to state I did
full justice to the meal. Mrs. P. & their son are down in Virginia for few days
so he decided to go with me to Mt. Vernon which we did on 2:30 o’clock boat. Did
not get there till four and grounds close at five so time was very limited but
felt well repaid for the trip. We left grounds shortly after five and I was low
enuf to pull a rose which I hope to get to my dearest one unless they apprehend
me or it falls entirely to pieces, which latter appears the more likely.
There were no more boats after five so we waited till six for a trolley thru
Alexandria, where we got off and went to see "Grace Church" where Washington
worshipped.... Then looked thru the old "Carlisle" house which is built on top of
an old fort, built in the early part of the 17th century (1700+ I mean) as
protection against the Indians and containing many prisons and dungeons. Then
went to the "Alexandria" house and after long wait at table were served a very
nice specially cooked dinner. Then came to Washington and left Senator at hotel.
At Mount Vernon we ran across three Democratic delegates from Washington just
returned from Baltimore. All were from our congressional district. One was
[Preston M.] Troy of Olympia-a brother to Senator [David S.] Troy-one [Eldridge]
Wheeler from Montesano, other Fitzburry [E. A. Fitzhenry] from Port Angelesin Clallam Count-a friend of Senator Troy’s.
When got back to hotel ran into them again and have been with them since till
started to write this epistle. We went up to see the fireworks....
My this is a "sweaty" country and my nose has bled some but got a light hat which
is great help to my head....
Bought little spoons at Mt. Vernon for the girls. First things except card I have
seen suitable. Did not go to Niagara from New York as I ran short of money. Hope
to from Pittsburg.
This is wonderful trip to me and if you were only along with more time at our
disposal would be almost perfect. So sorry you are not along except for danger of
you being overdone which would affect you all winter unfavorably at Olympia.
Will have to be here over tomorrow at least and possibly to first of next week,
when House Committee on Indian Affairs meets. Secured support of our men in the
Senate and it passed yesterday. The only question now appears to keep this
amendment from being thrown out in conference hope to obviate that by favorable
report from that Committee meeting first of next week. See it is going thru as
Senate Amendment to House bill which was passed without this included.
Lovingly, Harry
National Hotel, Washington, D.C.
[Friday,] July 5, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Pretty warm weather but the evenings are fine. Believe I would enjoy living in
this county-with an income of $7500.00 or so per year. Eating is pretty cheap
here I think. Get breakfast of mush, steak or chops etc, bread & butter, spuds,
coffee etc. for 25 cents and ½ fried chicken dinner with all fiings for 35
cents all along the avenue here. Of course these are not the most fashionable
places but pretty good at the price and much cheaper than I found in either New
York or Chicago.
Today I went first to see about that Indian legislation, there to incidentally
get a c’k cashed by Warburon-then took in the House & Senate in session-went to
Washington Monument and to the top thereo-then to Smithsonian Institute, which
closed at four before was half way thru of cours.... Then came to take"seeing
Washington" car, only to be much disappointed by learning, after hearing "in just
a minute" that there would be no more this evening, which aggravation was
increased when I saw four full big bus loads start off later and was informed
that it was a"special part" of school teachers from the West.
I went to Congressional Library this evening where could have found plenty to
occupy me for a week, but at 10 o’clock was told they had to close.
It is too murky to write more. Am in a sweat all over....
Lovingly, Harry
National Hotel, Washington, D.C.
[Sunday,] July 7, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Another day has gone by and I am not started home. That Indian Committee Meeting
seems "right on the verge" of occurring but has not yet gotten over, and have no
assurance just when it will be.
The matter was put on the General Indian Appropriation Bill as a Senate Amendment
to the House bill and passed with the rest of the bill, but some Montana Senator
felt he was aggrieved by the bill being passed in his absence and leaving off
some measure of interest to his State so they reconsidered, recalled the bill and
now will have to await disposing of the "Lorimer case" 4 before considering it
again. However, I do not have to wait on that because there appears little doubt
of it passing the Senate again, but the trouble arises in the House, where the
committee has not yet reported on the item and unless we can get them to repor
before the conference, which will occur after the amended bill passes the Senate,
the conference is liable to throw it out.
Warburton told me today that the committee should meet tomorrow or next Tuesday
at latest, but when he had seen the Chairman yesterday there was not a quorum in
town.
Lovingly, Harry
National Hotel, Washington, D.C.
[Tuesday,] July 9, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Has been the hottest of the summer today. Now 2:00 A.M. and just beginning to
cool off. Sitting in shirt sleeves and sweating while trying to write.Went to Bureau of Engraving & Printing today-then tried the Corcoran Art Gallery,
but it is closed for the summer. Went then to War, Navy & State Bldg. andenquired about whereabouts of [the Richardson relatives] Francis and Jack
Pryo....
I wired to LaSalle Hotel, Chicago, to forward any mail there to me here. I do
hope there will be some letters from you saying that all is OK. Hope the little
ones are doing well and getting rid of whooping cough.
Lovingly, Harry
On Train, 10:30 P.M.
[Wednesday,] July 10, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Homeward bound at last. Get to Pittsburg 6:00 A.M. tomorrow and hope to get cheap
excursion to Niagara. Indian Committee met today but no quorum. Try again Friday
but concluded to trust friends as quorum very uncertain....
Love to all, Harry
Papa did not explain the finer points of the legislative process to Mama in his
letters, but much later he reviewed the sequence of events in a letter to his
friend L. L. Bush of Bay Center:
You may remember that after the Chicago Convention two years ago, I went down to
Wash D. C. to urge along some action in the long delayed payment of the treaty
promises made to the different tribes of the lower Columbia in 1851. As it
happened, I got there at the critical time-after the Indian Appropriations hadleft the House (without this item) but before passing the Senate.
[George E.] Chamberlain had made the routine introductions of the bill for the
relief of the Oregon Indians and [Walter Lafferty], you know the Portland
Congressman, had likewise introduced it in the House just as had been done in
every Congress for years.Neither had appeared before the committee to urge the claim-it had not been considered or passed on by the Senate Committee. However,
it happened that Warburton was on a subcommittee of three that passed favorably
but never drew repor-he did not know that any Wash. Indians were concerned being
confused by old title of Oregon. Other two members of subcommittee were awa-one
seriously sick but W. got busy and tho we could not get needed majority of full
committee together, and they properly had no right to take that report without
other two (specially chairman) subcommittee signatures, after many days of
effort we succeeded before I left in getting promise of favorable action as soon
as committee could be gathered which was necessary before subsequent conference
committee could accept it. Also got promise of slated members of Congressional
committee to push it through. Happened also that [Wesley L.] Jones felt under
obligation tome...and he also got very busy on Senate end of i-had it added to the bill there. Poindexter also worked as best he could.... Great credit is due all
but especially Warburton. Congress would not even listen to interest which should
have been given but did allow theprincipal... Last month I took advantage of
coming election to urge Johnson who wrote he would do what he could.
Cleveland, Ohio, 7:30 P.M
[Saturday,] July 13, 1912
Dearest Helen,
Have not had opportunity to really write since I rec’d your bunch of letters at
Washingo....
I was caught in my first thunder shower little bit ago and got soaked so this is
from writing on my wet knee. Think it fixed my suit as had just got off a very
smoky dirty train and it surely will grind it in. Had only 3 blocks to go and did
that in the"lull" but was soaked anyway.
Lovingly, Harry
On Train
[Monday,] July 15, 1912
Dear Helen,
Am not yet in Chicago, but nearing it, having just left Columbia City, Ind. The
ground is here getting quite rolling, though it is all farmed. Eastern Ohio was
also rolling but the western two thirds of Ohio and Indiana to Fort Wayne were
quite level. Most too level it seems to me, as there was water standing on the ground in their hay and harvest fields. They certainly have more rain to bother
them than we have during harvets-but, on the other hand, can get more help & if
they do get a good day can put hay in the same day when cut or the next at
latest, whereas this early in season ours takes nearly a week to be ft....
Have passed thru very heavy rains today... Think I told you of my experience in
thunder shower in Cleveland. It cooled the atmosphere greatly, but according to
the papers, the next day Sunday was very hot all thru the district.
I was at Niagara and did not notice it greatly there, though many complained. Of
course it is much cooler there than further south and in the interior.
I enjoyed the time there hugely. It is certainly grand.
I do hope to find letters there [Chicago] from you and if possible some written
since I wired you regarding the cows. Am anxious to know if you understood and if
you effectedsale.... Hope you did. That would pay for my trip-and the pressing
deb....
Lovingly, Harry
Hanover, Wisconsin, 8:10 P.M.
[Tuesday,] July 16, 1912
Dearest Helen,
I think it must be ordered that I shall not get home this week. Every turn
something occurs to delay. We are now lying at this place which is merely a
station waiting for a new engine to take place of one broken down. They sent
ahead to Brodhead for one and after wait of about an hour got one (which is no
hitched on) about the size of some of those smaller ones on the Nahcotta-Megler
run....
Ten days later Papa was back in Oysterville, embraced warmly by his family and
friends, all of whom were eager to hear, firsthand, of his adventures.
Eventually, Papa did take Mama on the promised "grand tour" of the East-but not
until all their children were grown and gone. Even so, the momentous occasion
that was "remembered" for half a century and more was the summer when Papa was a
delegate.
1 Oysterville had served as Pacific County Seat from 1855 until 1893. In November
1892 voters elected South Bend as their new county seat. Citing irregularities in
the balloting, Oysterville residents called for a recount. Before that could
occur, however, a group of"South Bend Raiders" settled the matter by removing
the county records from the Oysterville Courthouse and taking them across
Shoalwater (now Willapa) Bay to South Bend. Papa, like many other Oystervillians,
always considered South Bend an"upstart" on the political scene.
2 Miles Poindexter (Progressive) from Spokane served as U.S. Senator from 1911 to
1923.
3 The preferential primary was in widespread use for the first time in 1912 and
was undoubtedly the basis for Papa’s prediction which implied that the direct
primary would eventually preempt the caucus/convention system. In fact, the
direct primary became the centerpiece of the Progressive movement and the most
lasting of the Progressive reforms. It is now the most common form of primary
election for all elected offices in the United States with the exception,
ironically, of the presidency.
4 Stanton Warburton (Progressive) from Washington’s Second District served as
U.S. Representative from 1911 to 1913.
4 The "Lorimer Case" involved charges of corrupt campaign procedures by Senator
William Lorimer (R., Ill.). After a lengthy and rancorous investigation the
matter was settled on July 13, 1912, when the Senate declared Lorimer’s 1909
election invalid and stripped him of his office.
Author Sydney Stevens is the great-granddaughter of R. H. Espy who, with his
partner I. A. Clark, founded Oysterville in 1854. Since retiring from a career in
teaching, she has devoted her time to researching and writing about the history
of the Oysterville area. Her most recent book is Dear Medora, Child of
Oysterville’s Forgotten Years. (Washington State University Press, 2007)
Teddy Roosevelt and the Bull Moose Party
Due to his disenchantment with President William Howard Taft over conservation
policy,"Teddy" Roosevelt was determined to run again for the presidency in 1912.
At the Republican National Convention in Chicago, however, the political bosses
saw to it that the pliable Taft, not Roosevelt, was renominated.
Roosevelt, who had served as the nation’s chief executive from 1901 to 1908,
still retained a large and loyal following. On the evening of June 22, 1912, the
former president asked his supporters to leave the floor of the convention. These
Republican"progressives" reconvened in Chicago’s Orchestra Hall and endorsed the
formation of a National Progressive Party with Roosevelt as its presidential
nominee. In response to the suggestion by reporters that he was no longer fit for
the office, Roosevelt retorted"I’m as fit as a bull moose," giving the new party
its nickname.
The Bull Moose Party was dedicated to needed social and political reforms as
America was becoming increasingly industrialized and urbanized in the early 20th
century. Their platform-"New Nationalism"-included women’s suffrage; direct
election of United States senators; the creation of an initiative, referendum,
and recall process; child labor laws; old-age pensions; a start to Native
American citizenship; and a national tariff reduction. The agenda had broad
support.
The national election became a three-way race between Taft, Roosevelt, and
Woodrow Wilson, the Democratic Party candidate. Splitting the Republican vote
with Taft, Roosevelt lost the general election to Democratic nominee Woodrow
Wilson, Roosevelt received 88 electoral votes and more than 4 million popularvotes, soundly outpacing Taft. No third party candidate has since come close to
Roosevelt’s success. A final indication of Roosevelt’s appeal and influence is
that most of his agenda became law, in several cases through a strenuous
constitutional amendment process.
In the state of Washington, Roosevelt received a plurality of the popular vote
(113,500); Wilson and Taft trailed with 86,600 and 70,100 votes, respectively.
However, each candidate was represented on the November 5, 1912, ballot by seven
electors from his party.
An interesting footnote: One of the seven Progressive electors in Washington was
Helen J. Scott. News reports at the time said that she was the first woman to
cast a vote in the electoral college-and therefore may be said to be the first
woman who voted for president. However, since some accounts also list women among
the Progressive electors in California, the matter is still a point of discussionamong historians.
Still Pending
The "claims of the Chinook Indians" to which Papa referred is listed in the
Congressional Record as Senate Report 503, "Final Settlement With Tillamook
Indians For Certain Oregon Lands" March 22, 1912, and states in part: "A bill to
provide for a settlement with the Wheelappa Band of Chinook Indians ofWashington for lands ceded by said Indians to the United States in a certain
unratified treaty between said parties, dated August 8, 1851"; also, the bill (S.
4535) entitled"A bill to provide for a final settlement with the Lower Band of
Chinook Indians of Washington for lands ceded by said Indians to the United
States in a certain unratified treaty between said parties, dated August 9, 1851..." from Senate Report No. 503, 62nd Congress, 2nd Session, 1912.
In the fall of 1914 Harry Espy wrote to Chinook chief George Charley:
Oysterville
October 5, 1914
Mr. Geo. Charley
Tokeland, Wash.
Friend Charley,
Getting tired of the failure to get the money here for the Chinook Indians, I
wrote to Washington D.C. urging some speed.
Congressman Johnson wrote me that he would do what he could and today I received
the following telegram from him:
(Dated: WA D.C. Today)
HON. H. A. ESPY
OYSTERVILLE, WASH
PAYMENT OF SIXTY SIX THOUSAND TO CHINOOK INDIANS TO BE MADE WITHIN TWO WEEKS
THROUGH AGENT OR CHESNEY [McChesney] AT TACOMA. LETTER OF AUTHORIZATION READY AT
INDIAN OFFICE. INDIVIDUAL CHECKS TO BE WRITTEN EACH TO BE RECEIPT IN FULL FOR
ALL CLAIMS
(signed) ALBERT JOHNSON [congressman from Hoquiam]
This looks better than for some time but judging from the past it promises it
will be nearer two months than two weeks before the Indians finally get the
money.
Please remember and try to have all your friends remember that the money would
not be coming soon after all these years except for the excellent work done by
Stanton Warburton two years ago. Senator Jones also did good work. Both are up
for election again 3rd of November.
The appropriation did, indeed, come through that October 1914, 53 long years
after the agreement made at Tansy Point in 1851. According to the 1914
Congressional Record, page 1791:"The money has gone forward and will be divided
at once among individuals of the tribes as follows"
Tillamooks of Oregon.....................................$10,500
Clatsops of Oregon........................................$15,000
Nuc-quee-clah-we-mucks of Oregon...........$1,500
Cathlamets of Washington...........................$7,000
Wahkiakums of Washington........................$7,000
Willapas of Washington................................$5,000
Lower Chinooks of Washington...................$20,000
However, according to Ray Gardner, current chairman of the Chinook Nation, only
the Clatsops accepted the appropriation. The other Chinook bands refused their
portion of the $66,000 which, without interest, came to less than 20 cents per
acre for the designated land. The appropriation was to be put in trust for the
Chinook Tribe until agreement on an amount could be reached. The matter is still
pending.